Former pastor accused of stealing nearly $70,000 from local church

Wednesday, November 13, 2019

By Scott Loftis

The former pastor of a Eureka Springs church faces felony charges after allegedly siphoning nearly $70,000 in donations for his personal use.

George Darryl Harris, 58, who served as pastor of New Day Fellowship Church on Passion Play Road, was arrested by a Carroll County Sheriff’s Office deputy on Oct. 25 on charges of theft of property and financial identity fraud.

After appearing before Carroll County District Judge Dale Ramsey on Oct. 28, Harris was released on his own recognizance and ordered to appear in Carroll County Circuit Court at 9 a.m. Monday, Dec. 2, in Berryville.

According to an affidavit written by CCSO investigator Jami Yarbrough, a representative of the church told a deputy that Harris opened an unauthorized bank account in the church’s name and then began depositing money from tithes into the account, without the knowledge of anyone at the church.

Paperwork provided by the church representative showed deposits into the account totaling $69,915, the affidavit says. The alleged embezzlement was discovered after church members began asking about discrepancies on their giving statements, according to the affidavit.

After being confronted by the church treasurer, the affidavit says, Harris confessed to taking the money. The church’s leadership team was notified and attempted to get Harris to close the account and repay the money, according to the affidavit. Harris did not close the account, however, and was asked to resign from the church, the affidavit says. According to the church representative who contacted the sheriff’s office, the deposits and withdrawals continued until April 2, 2019, the affidavit says. The church then contacted a lawyer to draft a promissory note “to assist Mr. Harris with paying the money back,” according to the affidavit, but Harris did not sign the note after receiving it through certified mail.

The church representative said a signed, notarized confession was obtained from Harris, the affidavit says, and a copy of that document is included with the affidavit.

Yarbrough contacted Harris by phone on Sept. 27 and asked for a statement of his version of events, the affidavit says.

“At first, Mr. Harris stated he did not know what I was talking about,” Yarbrough writes. “Once I advised I was looking at a file with a notarized, written confession signed by him, Mr. Harris informed me that he was represented by an attorney.”

Harris could not provide the name of the attorney, however, the affidavit says. Instead, he told Yarbrough that he was waiting on an attorney to call him back and might be able to provide the attorney’s name the following week.

In the undated confession included with the affidavit, Harris writes that he has resigned as pastor and will vacate his living quarters by June 1, 2019. He admits depositing 174 “separate items” from 47 individuals from March 2017 to April 2019.

“All of the checks were written to New Day Fellowship with the exception of approximately 14 checks made out to Darryl Harris,” he writes. “Most of the checks were marked clearly as tithes and offerings to NDF.”

Harris writes that he gained possession of the checks by members handing them directly to him, receiving them through the mail and secretly taking them from the church’s offering box.

“During my time as pastor at NDF people have handed me CASH that were clearly tithes and offerings intended for NDF, but that I kept personally,” Harris writes. “I do not know the total of the stolen cash.”

Harris goes on to write that in January 2019, he accepted an $800 cash offering designated toward the replacement of the church sign and kept the money for personal use. He writes that he repaid that money to the church member who originally donated it.

“Although a small portion of the money was spent on reasonable church ministry expenses, the MAJORITY of money was spent for the personal benefit of myself, my spouse, and my family,” Harris writes. “These expenses including Hunting supplies, Guns, Groceries, Recreation, Restaurants and general living expenses.”

In the final paragraph of the confession, Harris writes that he intends to make restitution to the church “for the financial damage my actions have caused.”

View 3 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Mother Teresa would be proud.

    -- Posted by Stormfield on Thu, Nov 14, 2019, at 5:04 PM
  • As an accountant for 40+ years, I’ve seen this occur many times whether in a ministry situation or with operations within public government. You must establish a system of financial internal controls to minimize the opportunity for thief to occur. This guy is a thief and should be punished according to the laws of man BUT he will live a miserable life and then face God with a final retribution. I’m sure these acts continue to occur within ES. There’s more to come.

    -- Posted by Saints4me on Fri, Nov 15, 2019, at 7:18 AM
  • Dear Pastor Darryl,

    I can't imagine the pain and humiliation that you, your wife, and family are going through right now. It's hard to look into the mirror or self many times and see what we truly are on the inside. Not completely, but a part of us, that is still capable of sin and that against GOD. Also the pain and the disappointment that is experienced by those around us. Gut wrenching!

    We wish we could disappear and if our heart is turned back toward GOD, Although there is justice (discipline) for our actions, there is mercy and grace of the blood JESUS shed for us... and for you at this time.

    We can never outrun HIS mercy, HIS grace, HIS love, and HIS willingness to bring us back into communion with HIM and with the rest of HIS kids in due time.

    I was one who came to New Day and I forgive you. I am sure that others do... at least those of us who know that we too are capable of FALLING at any given moment. Those who are 'religious' or say they haven't sinned, (for each and every is the same before GOD), are prideful and liars.

    I know you will have to face the consequences of what you have done, but I for one, after JESUS, come to 'lift your head.' You are not alone, for I have also fallen many times and have hurt and disappointed my GOD, my family and friends. But, in time, I was restored by LOVE HIMSELF, and when HE lifts our head, and we see HIM smile once more... there is no repeating of mistakes. I stand with you, brother, and I am praying for you and all! Blessings!

    -- Posted by GRACE4ALLWHO ASK on Mon, Nov 18, 2019, at 2:10 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: